Gentle Annie

James Craig

Lloyd Richland aka Rich Williams

Donna Reed

Mary Lingen

Marjorie Main

Annie Goss

Harry Morgan

Cottonwood Goss (as Henry Morgan)

Paul Langton

Violet Goss

Barton MacLane

Sheriff Tatum

John Philliber

Barrow

Morris Ankrum

Deputy Gansby

Noah Beery

Hansen (Noah Berry Sr.)

Frank Darien

Jake

Robert Emmett O'Connor

Childers the Bartender (as Robert Emmet O'Connor)