Sarah's Choice

Rebecca St. James

Sarah Collins

Andrea Logan White

Megan

Dick Van Patten

Rev. Al Smith

Brad Stine

Clay

Staci Keanan

Denise

Ethan Cooper Roy

Sam

Julian Bailey

Matt Evans

Robert Miano

Henry

Sidney Mason Gunn

Denise's daughter Sid

Sean McGowan

Jim

Brittany Yost

Secretary

Linda Bisesti

Agnes Collins